AN 5 The Book of the Fives – Pañcakanipāta > AN 5.167 Accusation

Numbered Discourses 5.167 – Aṅguttara Nikāya 5.167

17. Resentment – 17. Āghātavagga

AN 5.167 Accusation – Codanāsutta

1.1

There Sāriputta addressed the bhikkhū:

Tatra kho āyasmā sāriputto bhikkhū āmantesi:

1.2

“Reverends, a bhikkhu who wants to accuse another should first establish five things in themselves.

“codakena, āvuso, bhikkhunā paraṁ codetukāmena pañca dhamme ajjhattaṁ upaṭṭhāpetvā paro codetabbo.

2.1

What five?

Katame pañca?

2.2

I will speak at the right time, not at the wrong time.

Kālena vakkhāmi, no akālena;

2.3

I will speak truthfully, not falsely.

bhūtena vakkhāmi, no abhūtena;

2.4

I will speak gently, not harshly.

saṇhena vakkhāmi, no pharusena;

2.5

I will speak beneficially, not harmfully.

atthasaṁhitena vakkhāmi, no anatthasaṁhitena;

2.6

I will speak lovingly, not from secret hate.

mettacitto vakkhāmi, no dosantaro.

2.7

A bhikkhu who wants to accuse another should first establish these five things in themselves.

Codakena, āvuso, bhikkhunā paraṁ codetukāmena ime pañca dhamme ajjhattaṁ upaṭṭhāpetvā paro codetabbo.

3.1

Take a case where I see a certain person being accused at the wrong time, not being disturbed at the right time. They’re accused falsely, not disturbed truthfully. They’re accused harshly, not disturbed gently. They’re accused harmfully, not disturbed beneficially. They’re accused with secret hate, not disturbed lovingly.

Idhāhaṁ, āvuso, ekaccaṁ puggalaṁ passāmi akālena codiyamānaṁ no kālena kupitaṁ, abhūtena codiyamānaṁ no bhūtena kupitaṁ, pharusena codiyamānaṁ no saṇhena kupitaṁ, anatthasaṁhitena codiyamānaṁ no atthasaṁhitena kupitaṁ, dosantarena codiyamānaṁ no mettacittena kupitaṁ.

4.1

The bhikkhu who is accused improperly should be reassured in five ways.

Adhammacuditassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno pañcahākārehi avippaṭisāro upadahātabbo:

4.2

‘Venerable, you were accused at the wrong time, not at the right time. There’s no need for you to feel remorse.

‘akālenāyasmā cudito no kālena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

4.3

You were accused falsely, not truthfully. …

abhūtenāyasmā cudito no bhūtena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

4.4

You were accused harshly, not gently. …

pharusenāyasmā cudito no saṇhena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

4.5

You were accused harmfully, not beneficially. …

anatthasaṁhitenāyasmā cudito no atthasaṁhitena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

4.6

You were accused with secret hate, not lovingly. There’s no need for you to feel remorse.’

dosantarenāyasmā cudito no mettacittena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāyā’ti.

4.7

A bhikkhu who is accused improperly should be reassured in these five ways.

Adhammacuditassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno imehi pañcahākārehi avippaṭisāro upadahātabbo.

5.1

The bhikkhu who makes improper accusations should be chastened in five ways.

Adhammacodakassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno pañcahākārehi vippaṭisāro upadahātabbo:

5.2

‘Reverend, you made an accusation at the wrong time, not at the right time. There’s a reason for you to feel remorse.

‘akālena te, āvuso, codito no kālena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

5.3

You made an accusation falsely, not truthfully. …

abhūtena te, āvuso, codito no bhūtena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

5.4

You made an accusation harshly, not gently. …

pharusena te, āvuso, codito no saṇhena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

5.5

You made an accusation harmfully, not beneficially. …

anatthasaṁhitena te, āvuso, codito no atthasaṁhitena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

5.6

You made an accusation with secret hate, not lovingly. There’s a reason for you to feel remorse.’

dosantarena te, āvuso, codito no mettacittena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāyā’ti.

5.7

The bhikkhu who makes improper accusations should be chastened in these five ways.

Adhammacodakassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno imehi pañcahākārehi vippaṭisāro upadahātabbo.

5.8

Why is that?

Taṁ kissa hetu?

5.9

So that another bhikkhu wouldn’t think to make a false accusation.

Yathā na aññopi bhikkhu abhūtena codetabbaṁ maññeyyāti.

6.1

Take a case where I see a certain person being accused at the right time, not being disturbed at the wrong time. They’re accused truthfully, not disturbed falsely. They’re accused gently, not disturbed harshly. They’re accused beneficially, not disturbed harmfully. They’re accused lovingly, not disturbed with secret hate.

Idha panāhaṁ, āvuso, ekaccaṁ puggalaṁ passāmi kālena codiyamānaṁ no akālena kupitaṁ, bhūtena codiyamānaṁ no abhūtena kupitaṁ, saṇhena codiyamānaṁ no pharusena kupitaṁ, atthasaṁhitena codiyamānaṁ no anatthasaṁhitena kupitaṁ, mettacittena codiyamānaṁ no dosantarena kupitaṁ.

7.1

The bhikkhu who is accused properly should be chastened in five ways.

Dhammacuditassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno pañcahākārehi vippaṭisāro upadahātabbo:

7.2

‘Venerable, you were accused at the right time, not at the wrong time. There’s a reason for you to feel remorse.

‘kālenāyasmā cudito no akālena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

7.3

You were accused truthfully, not falsely. …

bhūtenāyasmā cudito no abhūtena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

7.4

You were accused gently, not harshly. …

saṇhenāyasmā cudito no pharusena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

7.5

You were accused beneficially, not harmfully. …

atthasaṁhitenāyasmā cudito no anatthasaṁhitena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāya;

7.6

You were accused lovingly, not with secret hate. There’s a reason for you to feel remorse.’

mettacittenāyasmā cudito no dosantarena, alaṁ te vippaṭisārāyā’ti.

7.7

The bhikkhu who is accused properly should be chastened in these five ways.

Dhammacuditassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno imehi pañcahākārehi vippaṭisāro upadahātabbo.

8.1

The bhikkhu who makes proper accusations should be reassured in five ways.

Dhammacodakassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno pañcahākārehi avippaṭisāro upadahātabbo:

8.2

‘Reverend, you made an accusation at the right time, not at the wrong time. There’s no need for you to feel remorse.

‘kālena te, āvuso, codito no akālena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

8.3

You made an accusation truthfully, not falsely. …

bhūtena te, āvuso, codito no abhūtena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

8.4

You made an accusation gently, not harshly. …

saṇhena te, āvuso, codito no pharusena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

8.5

You made an accusation beneficially, not harmfully. …

atthasaṁhitena te, āvuso, codito no anatthasaṁhitena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāya;

8.6

You made an accusation lovingly, not with secret hate. There’s no need for you to feel remorse.’

mettacittena te, āvuso, codito no dosantarena, alaṁ te avippaṭisārāyā’ti.

8.7

The bhikkhu who makes proper accusations should be reassured in these five ways.

Dhammacodakassa, āvuso, bhikkhuno imehi pañcahākārehi avippaṭisāro upadahātabbo.

8.8

Why is that?

Taṁ kissa hetu?

8.9

So that another bhikkhu would think to make a true accusation.

Yathā aññopi bhikkhu bhūtena coditabbaṁ maññeyyāti.

9.1

A person who is accused should ground themselves in two things:

Cuditena, āvuso, puggalena dvīsu dhammesu patiṭṭhātabbaṁ—

9.2

truth and an even temper.

sacce ca, akuppe ca.

9.3

Even if others accuse me—at the right time or the wrong time, truthfully or falsely, gently or harshly, beneficially or harmfully, lovingly or with secret hate—I will still ground myself in two things:

Mañcepi, āvuso, pare codeyyuṁ kālena vā akālena vā bhūtena vā abhūtena vā saṇhena vā pharusena vā atthasaṁhitena vā anatthasaṁhitena vā mettacittā vā dosantarā vā, ahampi dvīsuyeva dhammesu patiṭṭhaheyyaṁ—

9.4

truth and an even temper.

sacce ca, akuppe ca.

9.5

If I know that

Sace jāneyyaṁ:

9.6

that quality is found in me, I will tell them that it is.

‘attheso mayi dhammo’ti, ‘atthī’ti naṁ vadeyyaṁ:

9.7

‘saṁvijjateso mayi dhammo’ti.

9.8

If I know that

Sace jāneyyaṁ:

9.9

that quality is not found in me, I will tell them that it is not.”

‘nattheso mayi dhammo’ti, ‘natthī’ti naṁ vadeyyaṁ:

9.10

‘neso dhammo mayi saṁvijjatī’”ti.

10.1

“Even when you speak like this, Sāriputta, there are still some foolish people here who do not respectfully take it up.”

“Evampi kho te, sāriputta, vuccamānā atha ca panidhekacce moghapurisā na padakkhiṇaṁ gaṇhantī”ti.

11.1

“Sir, there are those faithless people who went forth from the lay life to homelessness not out of faith but to earn a livelihood. They’re devious, deceitful, and sneaky. They’re restless, insolent, fickle, scurrilous, and loose-tongued. They do not guard their sense doors or eat in moderation, and they are not dedicated to wakefulness. They don’t care about the ascetic life, and don’t keenly respect the training. They’re indulgent and slack, leaders in backsliding, neglecting seclusion, lazy, and lacking energy. They’re unmindful, lacking situational awareness and samādhi, with straying minds, witless and stupid. When I speak to them like this, they don’t respectfully take it up.

“Ye te, bhante, puggalā assaddhā jīvikatthā na saddhā agārasmā anagāriyaṁ pabbajitā saṭhā māyāvino ketabino uddhatā unnaḷā capalā mukharā vikiṇṇavācā indriyesu aguttadvārā bhojane amattaññuno jāgariyaṁ ananuyuttā sāmaññe anapekkhavanto sikkhāya na tibbagāravā bāhulikā sāthalikā okkamane pubbaṅgamā paviveke nikkhittadhurā kusītā hīnavīriyā muṭṭhassatino asampajānā asamāhitā vibbhantacittā duppaññā eḷamūgā, te mayā evaṁ vuccamānā na padakkhiṇaṁ gaṇhanti.

12.1

Sir, there are those gentlemen who went forth from the lay life to homelessness out of faith. They’re not devious, deceitful, and sneaky. They’re not restless, insolent, fickle, scurrilous, and loose-tongued. They guard their sense doors and eat in moderation, and they are dedicated to wakefulness. They care about the ascetic life, and keenly respect the training. They’re not indulgent or slack, nor are they leaders in backsliding, neglecting seclusion. They’re energetic and determined. They’re mindful, with situational awareness, samādhi, and unified minds; wise, not stupid. When I speak to them like this, they do respectfully take it up.”

Ye pana te, bhante, kulaputtā saddhā agārasmā anagāriyaṁ pabbajitā asaṭhā amāyāvino aketabino anuddhatā anunnaḷā acapalā amukharā avikiṇṇavācā indriyesu guttadvārā bhojane mattaññuno jāgariyaṁ anuyuttā sāmaññe apekkhavanto sikkhāya tibbagāravā na bāhulikā na sāthalikā okkamane nikkhittadhurā paviveke pubbaṅgamā āraddhavīriyā pahitattā upaṭṭhitassatino sampajānā samāhitā ekaggacittā paññavanto aneḷamūgā, te mayā evaṁ vuccamānā padakkhiṇaṁ gaṇhantī”ti.

13.1

“Sāriputta, those faithless people who went forth from the lay life to homelessness not out of faith but to earn a livelihood … Leave them be.

“Ye te, sāriputta, puggalā assaddhā jīvikatthā na saddhā agārasmā anagāriyaṁ pabbajitā saṭhā māyāvino ketabino uddhatā unnaḷā capalā mukharā vikiṇṇavācā indriyesu aguttadvārā bhojane amattaññuno jāgariyaṁ ananuyuttā sāmaññe anapekkhavanto sikkhāya na tibbagāravā bāhulikā sāthalikā okkamane pubbaṅgamā paviveke nikkhittadhurā kusītā hīnavīriyā muṭṭhassatino asampajānā asamāhitā vibbhantacittā duppaññā eḷamūgā, tiṭṭhantu te.

14.1

But those gentlemen who went forth from the lay life to homelessness out of faith … You should speak to them.

Ye pana te, sāriputta, kulaputtā saddhā agārasmā anagāriyaṁ pabbajitā asaṭhā amāyāvino aketabino anuddhatā anunnaḷā acapalā amukharā avikiṇṇavācā indriyesu guttadvārā bhojane mattaññuno jāgariyaṁ anuyuttā sāmaññe apekkhavanto sikkhāya tibbagāravā na bāhulikā na sāthalikā okkamane nikkhittadhurā paviveke pubbaṅgamā āraddhavīriyā pahitattā upaṭṭhitassatino sampajānā samāhitā ekaggacittā paññavanto aneḷamūgā, te tvaṁ, sāriputta, vadeyyāsi.

14.2

Sāriputta, you should advise your spiritual companions!

Ovada, sāriputta, sabrahmacārī;

14.3

You should instruct your spiritual companions!

anusāsa, sāriputta, sabrahmacārī:

14.4

Thinking: ‘I will draw my spiritual companions away from false teachings and ground them in true teachings.’

‘asaddhammā vuṭṭhāpetvā saddhamme patiṭṭhāpessāmi sabrahmacārī’ti.

14.5

That’s how you should train.”

Evañhi te, sāriputta, sikkhitabban”ti.

14.6

Sattamaṁ.